Osteria Cardo A seasonal Italian restaurant in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Overhead view of hand-cut pappardelle with braised short rib ragù and Parmigiano on a white plate, on a dark walnut table beside a striped linen napkin and a glass of red wine
CoverHand-cut pappardelle with braised short rib ragù and Parmigiano Reggiano, the dish that opens the autumn menu.
From the kitchenp. 02

Why does our Italian menu change with the Brooklyn seasons?

Because that is how Italians have always cooked: what’s ripe, what’s close, and what tastes best this week.

Every osteria in Italy cooks from its own hillside. Ours happens to be the greenmarkets at Grand Army Plaza and Union Square, and a handful of farms in the Hudson Valley, the North Fork and southern New Jersey that deliver to Court Street twice a week. When the first Jersey tomatoes arrive, they go on the menu. When they’re gone, so is the dish.

The pasta is rolled at 9 a.m. by hand, using Italian 00 flour and eggs from a farm in Columbia County. We make between six and eight shapes each week, cut to suit the sauce: wide pappardelle for slow braises, pinched agnolotti for squash and brown butter, thin tagliolini for anything with a lemon in it.

We name ourselves after the cardoon, a thistle-like cousin of the artichoke that Italian grandmothers fry, bake and braise every winter, and that most New Yorkers have never tasted. It’s a fair summary of what we’re about: unglamorous ingredients, cooked with care, at the moment they’re best.

The result is a menu that is never quite the same twice. Regulars come back for the pastas they know and stay for the plate they didn’t expect. Newcomers get a straight answer to “what’s good tonight?” — usually whatever came in that morning.

Delicata squash, fresh sage leaves and a cardoon stalk arranged on a marble kitchen counter in natural afternoon light
Plate IDelicata squash, sage and cardoon: three autumn ingredients from farms within a few hours of Court Street.

“If it isn’t growing within a few hours of Court Street, it waits for its season.”

The kitchen’s one rule
The calendarp. 04

What’s on the menu in each season?

Four menus a year, each built around a handful of ingredients at their peak. Here’s what to expect, and when to come back.

Spring

March to May

  • Ramps & wild garlic
  • English peas & fava beans
  • Asparagus
  • Rhubarb

Signature: ramp agnolotti with pecorino and lemon.

Summer

June to August

  • Jersey tomatoes
  • Sweet corn
  • Zucchini blossoms
  • Peaches & plums

Signature: sweet corn cappelletti, brown butter, chilli.

On the menu now

Autumn

September to November

  • Winter squash
  • Maitake & wild mushrooms
  • Concord grapes
  • Apples & pears

Signature: pappardelle with braised short rib ragù.

Winter

December to February

  • Blood oranges
  • Chicories & radicchio
  • Cardoons
  • Slow braises

Signature: cardoon gratin and Sunday osso buco.

Ways to dinep. 05

How much does dinner cost, and which way should you book?

A quick bowl of pasta at the bar or five courses for a birthday: compare our four ways to eat at Osteria Cardo.

Candlelit dining room of Osteria Cardo with linen-covered wooden tables, a marble bar and wine shelves in the early evening
The room42 seats, an eight-seat marble bar and candles lit from 5 p.m.
Prices per person, before tax and gratuity.
OptionPriceWhat you getBest forHow to book
À la carteTuesday to Sunday$14–$42Order freely from antipasti, pasta, secondi and dolci. Most guests spend $65–$85 with wine.Weeknight dinners, a pasta and a glass of wine at the barReserve online or walk in
Fidati tasting menu“Fidati” means “trust us”$85Five courses chosen by the kitchen. Optional $55 pairing from small Italian producers.Birthdays, anniversaries, first visitsBook 48 hours ahead; whole table participates
Sunday supperSundays from noon$55Three courses served family-style on big platters to share, including a weekly roast.Families and groups of 4 to 10Reserve online; walk-ins welcome
Private diningBack room or full buyoutfrom $95Four-course seasonal menu, family-style, with a dedicated server. Up to 18 or up to 50 guests.Rehearsal dinners, team dinners, milestone birthdaysSend an enquiry 2+ weeks ahead
Letters to the kitchenp. 06

What our neighbours say about dinner on Court Street

Notes from the people who keep coming back.

Add a short quote from a real customer here.

Customer name · What they bought or where they're from

Add a short quote from a real customer here.

Customer name · What they bought or where they're from

Add a short quote from a real customer here.

Customer name · What they bought or where they're from
Reservations & private diningp. 07
Book a table

Reserve a table at Osteria Cardo

Tell us when you’d like to come and how many of you there are. We confirm every request personally by email, usually within a few hours.

Planning something bigger? Choose “Private event” and we’ll send menus, availability and pricing for the back room (up to 18 guests) or the whole restaurant (up to 50).

Long wooden table set for a family-style Sunday supper with shared platters of roast chicken, branzino and polenta, hands passing dishes
Sunday supperFamily-style platters to pass, the same way we serve private dinners in the back room.
  • TonightCall (555) 010-2030 from 3 p.m.
  • Walk-insBar seats and a few tables held every night
  • GroupsParties of 7+ book through this form
  • AllergiesTell us when you book; the kitchen plans ahead

Request a reservation

Fields marked optional can be left blank.

This is a request, not a confirmed booking. We’ll reply by email to confirm.
Visitp. 08
Carroll Park SMITH ST COURT ST CLINTON ST CARROLL ST PRESIDENT ST F G Osteria Cardo 4 min walk

MapIllustrative only. Four minutes on foot from the Carroll Street F/G station.

Find us

Where is Osteria Cardo, and when is it open?

Warmly lit restaurant storefront with a deep red façade on a tree-lined Carroll Gardens street at dusk, with autumn leaves and a bicycle out front
Look forThe deep red façade on Court Street, lit up from 5 p.m.
123 Court Street
Brooklyn, NY 11231
Opening hours
MondayClosed
Tuesday – Thursday5:30 – 10 p.m.
Friday – Saturday5 – 11 p.m.
Sunday12 – 9 p.m. (supper from noon)
  • F or G train to Carroll Street, 4-minute walk
  • Bike racks out front; limited street parking on weekends
  • Step-free dining room and restroom
Questions & answersp. 09
FAQ

Before you come for dinner

The questions we hear most on the phone. Anything else, call (555) 010-2030 or write to hello@example.com.

Q.01Do I need a reservation at Osteria Cardo?

Reservations are recommended but not required. We hold the eight-seat bar and a few tables for walk-ins every night. Weeknights before 6:30 p.m. are the easiest time to walk in, while Friday and Saturday tables usually book up about a week ahead.

Q.02How often does the menu change?

The full menu changes four times a year, and individual dishes change almost weekly. Each season we rewrite the menu around what New York and New Jersey farms are harvesting, then swap plates as produce comes and goes at the greenmarket. Our fresh pasta shapes follow the same calendar.

Q.03How much does dinner at Osteria Cardo cost?

Most guests spend $65 to $85 per person, including a glass of wine. Antipasti run $14 to $19, pastas $24 to $28 and secondi $29 to $42. The five-course Fidati tasting menu is $85 per person, with an optional $55 wine pairing from small Italian producers.

Q.04Do you have vegetarian or gluten-free options?

Yes, every menu includes vegetarian dishes, and at least two pastas are always meat-free. We make gluten-free pasta in a separate batch each afternoon. Our kitchen handles flour all day, though, so we can't promise zero cross-contact for guests with coeliac disease. Tell us about allergies when you book.

Q.05Can I book Osteria Cardo for a private event?

Yes, our back room seats up to 18 guests, and the whole restaurant can be booked for up to 50. Private dinners are served family-style from a seasonal menu starting at $95 per person. Send an enquiry using the form on this page and we'll reply within two business days.

Q.06Is Osteria Cardo good for children?

Yes, children are welcome, especially at Sunday supper. We keep high chairs and booster seats, and the kitchen will happily make a small bowl of butter-and-parmesan pasta for younger diners. Friday and Saturday evenings get busier and louder after 8 p.m., so earlier seatings tend to suit families best.

Q.07How do I get to Osteria Cardo?

Take the F or G train to Carroll Street, then walk about four minutes to Court Street. Street parking is limited on weekends, and there are bike racks out front. The dining room and restroom are step-free and wheelchair accessible; let us know if you need a particular table.

Tonight, or any night this season

Pull up a chair on Court Street.

The autumn menu runs until the end of November. Squash, maitake and short rib won’t wait, and neither will Friday’s tables.